Collective Impact #Toolbox: After Action Reviews

Collective Impact #Toolbox: After Action Reviews

Want to build a feedback culture? Use this fast, simple U.S. Army process to reflect, capture learning, and improve how your partnership works together over time.

The Collective Impact #ToolBox is a series of blogs featuring simple, practical tools that members of cross-sector partnerships can use to support their day to day work.

Consistent reflection, whether by individuals or teams, is an important ingredient for growth and improvement. Individual reflection rarely requires a meeting or a process. Many of us are constantly reflecting on our intentions, our results and how we can improve. It is often so natural, we don’t even realize we are doing it! It is much more difficult for groups to reflect effectively without dedicated time and structure. In groups, there are multiple voices and perspectives that must be channeled into actionable learning about what’s working, what isn’t, and why. Additionally, if a group has not already developed the trust and common understanding necessary for a feedback culture to thrive, reflection sessions can become wrought with defensiveness, accusations and nonconstructive criticism.

I was trained on a great tool for navigating challenging group dynamics during my time serving in the United States Army.

The U.S. Army is made up of teams that are called upon to navigate these group dynamics in particularly stressful and transitory environments. They must gel quickly, communicate well and consistently improve when the stakes are high. One of the most effective tools that the Army developed to support leaders to meet these challenges is the After Action Review (AAR). After every mission or training exercise, soldiers gather around a leader or designated facilitator. At least one person is selected to take notes. Someone is called upon to restate the mission and intent. Then the group collectively describes what actually happened. Next, the team surfaces opportunities for improvement, and highlights things that went well and should be sustained in the future. Once complete, the notes are either entered into a formal report and shared so others can benefit from the learning, or simply entered into a team AAR book so that next time a similar mission or exercise will be conducted, the learning can be easily referenced.

As both a member of the Living Cities staff and as an Army Reserve Officer, I have facilitated and participated in countless AARs. The great thing about AARs – they are made up of four simple questions. The questions can be productively answered in five minutes or in fifty minutes. They work for reflecting on complex initiatives as well as for simple exercises. The added structure helps teams get into a rhythm of giving feedback while keeping the focus on actionable learning instead of finger-pointing. For all of these reasons the frame has been adapted for use by the for-profit and non-profit sectors. It’s a great technique for cross-sector partnerships to employ in service of learning to work together differently.

Here are two excellent resources if you are interested in learning more about how to facilitate AARs well:

U.S. Army Leader’s Guide to After Action Reviews

The Army training curricula packed with 35 pages of no non-sense “how to” details so that every leader benefits from foundational knowledge of how to facilitate the AAR process.

Knowledge Sharing Toolkit’s Adapted AAR Guide

A simple, non-military adapted explanation with tips, examples, and links to other supports.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Latest Articles

Living Cities Selected to the ImpactAssets 50 for 11th Year in a Row

Living Cities’ Capital for the New Majority team is thrilled to announce that Living Cities and the Catalyst Family of Funds have been selected to the ImpactAssets 50 (IA 50) for the eleventh consecutive year and named as an Emeritus Impact Manager for the second time. “Now in its eleventh year, the ImpactAssets 50™ is the most recognized free database of …

Founders First’s Innovative Financing Supports Entrepreneurs of Color

Kim Folsom knows what it means to be a Black woman entrepreneur. Even after founding and running seven successful businesses, she still feels “like a square peg in a round hole,” she says. Yet Folsom is representative of what it will take to use capital in innovative and transformative ways to create broader systems change. Her latest venture, Founders First, …

Pulse Checking Progress Toward Operationalizing REI: Arts, Culture & Healing

In 2017, we released an internal learning report titled  “What Does it Take to Embed a Racial Equity & Inclusion Lens?” that captures themes from internal interviews, a field scan, and learnings from our grantmaking and investments in cities across the country. There were twelve themes we uncovered in our scan of practices being used by organizations to operationalize racial …

Pulse Checking Progress Toward Operationalizing REI: Shifting Systems Of Power

In 2017, we released an internal learning report titled  “What Does it Take to Embed a Racial Equity & Inclusion Lens?” that captures themes from internal interviews, a field scan, and learnings from our grantmaking and investments in cities across the country. There were twelve themes we uncovered in our scan of practices being used by organizations to operationalize racial equity.These …

Get Updates

We want to stay in touch with you! Sign up for our email list to receive updates on the progress we’re making with our network of partners, as well as helpful resources and blog posts.

Name