Pay for Success: Living Cities’ Initial Screening Criteria

Pay for Success: Living Cities’ Initial Screening Criteria

The Initial Screening Criteria infographic provides an overview of how Living Cities decides which Pay for Success projects to consider investing in. The criteria is listed in a check-box format for the use of our networks and partners.


The Pay for Success (PFS) field continues to gain traction. As one of the earliest investors in PFS transactions in the United States. Each project we’ve been involved with–whether or not we ultimately invested— has informed our thinking on the potential PFS has to be a tool to get better outcomes for low-income people. Now, with six investments under our belt, the Living Cities team has been in a unique position to grow the field, contributing our lessons and resources for future investments.

A New Screen for a Growing Field
Our initial screening criteria designed to assess whether a project is a good use of the PFS model, and if it is a good fit with Living Cities’ programmatic priorities. We look for: impact; innovation; collaboration; a government champion; and programmatic significance.

Download the full infographic and get a check-list of all the elements Living Cities considers when deciding whether to invest in a Pay For Success transaction.

Our Team honed the criteria based on feedback from staff, members and our Blended Catalyst Fund investors. Our initial screening criteria will likely evolve as we continue to learn. But in the Living Cities spirit of open-sourcing, we’re sharing our criteria now in the hopes that others will be able to use it to inform their work.

Please submit your feedback, stories of use, or suggestions in the comment section of this resource.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

More Resources

Living Cities Blended Catalyst Fund 2023 Annual Report

This report summarizes the eighth year of operations for Living Cities Blended Catalyst Fund’s (“BCF” or the “Fund”) activities, from July 1, 2022, through June 30, 2023 (FY23). We thank you for your support and are excited to explore and share lessons learned as our portfolio continues to mature. The BCF portfolio is a collection of investments that work to …

Beyond 5: Business Survivability Study for New Majority Entrepreneurs

Beyond 5 is a Business Survivability Study for New Majority Entrepreneurs produced by 1863 Ventures with funding from Living Cities, Surdna Foundation, Wells Fargo, M&T Bank, Capital One and Georgetown University. The 1863 Ventures team found that Black and brown businesses survive at least 8.5 years, compared to the median of six years. What would it take to support BIPOC …

Takeaways from Our Discussion about Equitable Small Business Opportunity and Good Jobs Tied to Infrastructure and Climate Investments

Promoting business opportunities for all, while creating good jobs and developing shovel worthy infrastructure and climate action projects, is not a pipe dream. And yet our traditional ways of operating won’t get us there. Simple spending more, rather than smarter and more fairly, won’t be enough. Business as usual is neither inclusive, protective or coordinated enough, and it often lacks …

Living Cities, Urban Institute Research Report: A Landscape Scan of Homeownership for Households of Color

Homeownership has been a primary wealth-building opportunity in the U.S., and can impact a family’s economic outcomes across generations. Living Cities partnered with the Urban Institute to provide data for the six cohort cities, the five states where these cohort cities are located, and nationally around homeownership for households of color. The research report, “A Landscape Scan of Homeownership for …

Get Updates

We want to stay in touch with you! Sign up for our email list to receive updates on the progress we’re making with our network of partners, as well as helpful resources and blog posts.

Name